Contract Tax Review Insights #2

As a general rule, VAT is neutral for businesses carrying out taxable activities.

However, this is often not the case for FinTech companies.

Financial services are generally VAT-exempt, which means that companies providing them may have restricted rights to recover input VAT.

In other words, VAT incurred for goods and services purchased by FinTechs can become an additional cost, increasing the actual purchase price.

Why Should FinTech Businesses Consider VAT Before Signing a Contract?

FinTech groups frequently buy goods and services for the benefit of several entities within the group, often involving substantial amounts.

In the case of cross-border purchases of services or intra-EU acquisitions of goods, business and procurement teams often do not factor VAT into the overall cost of the transaction as they expect suppliers to issue invoices without charging VAT.

However, the absence of VAT on the supplier’s invoice does not mean that no VAT arises.

Depending on the nature of the supply and the applicable VAT rules, it is often the buyer who is required to self-charge VAT on the purchased services or acquired goods.

This is where the key question arises: How much of the self-charged VAT can actually be recovered by the FinTech company?

For high-value contracts, even partially irrecoverable VAT can materially change the cost of the purchase.

During commercial negotiations, five questions should therefore be addressed.

The following questions apply to different types of purchases, although the examples focus primarily on services, which are particularly relevant to FinTech businesses.

1. What Is Actually Being Purchased and how it is treated for VAT purposes?

The VAT analysis starts with gaining of clear understanding what the company is actually purchasing: goods, services or a mixture of both.

The contractual description does not always reflect the nature of the supply and does not, on its own, determine its VAT treatment. For example, a platform agreement may cover several components: access to software, delivery of hardware components, implementation, staff training and ongoing support.

Understanding the actual nature of the supply is essential for determining its VAT treatment, particularly the place of supply, who should account for VAT, the applicable VAT rate and whether an exemption applies

This preliminary assessment should take place before the contractual terms and invoicing arrangements are reviewed.

2. Who Will Actually Benefit from the Purchase and for What Purpose?

Let’s take a common example: the purchase of a SaaS solution for the benefit of several entities within a FinTech group, some carrying out taxable activities and others VAT-exempt activities.

The tax analysis must follow the business reality. It is therefore important to understand which entities will actually benefit from the service, which teams will use it, for what purposes and in which jurisdictions.

These details matter because the right to recover input VAT depends, among other things, on how the purchased services are used in the business. Where the service supports VAT-exempt activities, some or all of the related input VAT may become irrecoverable.

A service used across several group entities may therefore have different VAT cost implications depending on the activities carried out by the entities involved. For some entities, VAT may be fully recoverable, while for others it may not be.

3. Which Entity Should Enter Into the Agreement?

One of the most important questions in a contractual tax review is whether the appropriate group entity is entering into the agreement.

If the agreement is entered into by an entity with restricted VAT recovery rights, some or all of the VAT may become an irrecoverable cost, increasing the actual purchase price.

However, the choice of contracting entity cannot be considered in isolation from the actual business arrangements.

The analysis becomes particularly interesting in centralised procurement structures. Frequently, one group company negotiates and initially bears the cost of a service that is subsequently used by other entities within the group. In such cases, the contractual structure should reflect the actual arrangements for receiving, using and allocating the cost.

The seemingly simple question “Which entity should sign?” may therefore have a direct impact on the group’s overall VAT cost.

4. What Happens to VAT at Each Stage?

Where a service is purchased centrally and subsequently made available to other group entities, the VAT analysis does not necessarily end with the original supplier’s invoice.

A second layer of questions arises: should the cost be recharged within the group, what is the VAT treatment of that recharge, and how much of the resulting VAT will ultimately remain irrecoverable at each stage?

Depending on the arrangements, intra-group charges may give rise to additional VAT obligations, while the receiving entities may have different rights to recover that VAT.

The objective is not simply to identify the VAT treatment of the initial purchase, but to understand the overall VAT cost for the group.

In some cases, irrecoverable VAT will simply be unavoidable.

5. Are the VAT and Invoicing Clauses Clear and Accurate?

Finally, the VAT provisions and invoicing clauses in the agreement should be reviewed carefully.

In practice, agreements do not always make clear whether VAT is included in the agreed price or should be charged in addition to it.

Clear pricing and VAT provisions are important for the teams responsible for VAT compliance, particularly where they need to determine the amount of VAT to be accounted for and the recoverable and irrecoverable amounts under the applicable local rules.

There are also cases where suppliers charge VAT even though the particular supply should be invoiced without VAT, with the recipient being responsible to account for it under the reverse-charge mechanism. VAT charged in error is generally not deductible as input VAT, and corrections from the supplier can take time.

VAT identification numbers may be missing or incorrectly stated, potentially creating compliance issues in the recipient’s jurisdiction. In other cases, the invoicing provisions in the agreement simply do not reflect the processes actually followed by the company.

These inconsistencies may not always create significant tax exposure, but they often have a cost: corrections to purchase orders and invoices, additional communication with suppliers, adjustments to VAT reporting and hours of internal administrative work.

Reviewing these details before the agreement is signed can prevent unnecessary complications later.

The Contract Is the First Checkpoint

The answers to these five questions may lead to a very different view of the same transaction.

Sometimes the original structure will be entirely appropriate. Sometimes the invoicing flow will need to change. In other cases, a different group entity may need to become the contracting party.

What matters is that the business understands the VAT cost before the price is agreed.

A seemingly standard SaaS agreement can raise questions concerning input VAT recovery, allocation of shared costs, intra-group recharges, the characterization of the service and, ultimately, whether the contractual structure reflects how the service is actually used in the business.

Coming Next – Insight #3

The Hidden Cost of Gross-Up Clauses: Who Really Bears the Withholding Tax?

Comments are closed.

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.