FinTech scale-ups enter into numerous cross-border contracts every month, covering SaaS products, platform solutions, global licensing arrangements, marketing services, distribution, etc.

A contract that appears flawless from a commercial and legal perspective may still contain tax risks that materially increase the potential or actual cost of the transaction.

In my practice, I assess such cross-border contracts on a daily basis. Depending on the jurisdictions involved and the nature of the contract, the additional tax exposure can exceed 1/3 of the fee payable by the FinTech company. Consider, for example, a regulated company in Germany acquiring time-limited licensing rights from a foreign supplier: a gross-up clause shifts the economic burden of withholding tax onto the buyer, to which are added 19% VAT self-charged by the buyer but irrecoverable due to its VAT-exempt activities as well as German trade tax.

The problem is rarely a lack of tax expertise within the company. It is that the in-house tax teams struggle to cover the large volume of contracts in time. In-house tax teams are under constant pressure of strict filing obligations across multiple jurisdictions, ever new reporting requirements, tax audits, and restructurings. Understandably, contract reviews often take a back seat. As a result, the tax cost often becomes apparent only after the deal structure has been agreed and the invoice has been issued.

In my experience, the most common tax issues fall into three main categories.

1.  VAT as a Real Cost

For FinTech companies, irrecoverable VAT is one of the most typical tax costs. The VAT-exempt financial services provided by regulated entities restrict their right to recover input VAT. As a result, VAT due on purchases of software, SaaS, marketing, and consulting services often becomes a cost, either partially or in full.

Which group entity signs the contract, which entity actually receives and uses the service, and how the cost is subsequently allocated within the group can all have a direct impact on the overall cost of the transaction.

2.  Hidden Withholding Taxes and Country-Specific Tax Costs

Standard tax clauses in international contracts can quietly shift the economic burden of withholding taxes or certain digital services taxes onto the buyer. In certain jurisdictions, taxes contractually borne by the buyer may also be non-deductible for corporate income tax purposes, further increasing the effective cost of the transaction. Managing this risk requires the correct qualification of the services and payments under domestic tax law, the applicable double tax treaty and, increasingly taking into account any relevant modifications introduced by the Multilateral Instrument.

3.  Reclassification of Working Arrangements and Permanent Establishment Risk

International contractors, freelancers, and Employer of Record platforms have become a routine part of many FinTech business models.

Depending on the contractual terms and, more importantly, how the arrangements operate in practice, these relationships may be reclassified as employment or even give rise to permanent establishment exposure in another jurisdiction.

The consequences may include additional tax liabilities, social security obligations, and administrative compliance requirements.

Beyond these three categories, other risks include transfer pricing, contractual clauses through which vendors seek to shift DAC6 reporting responsibilities onto their customers, specific local taxes associated with leasing business premises.

The Contract as the First Checkpoint

The objective of the business is neither to subject every contract to an exhaustive tax analysis nor to use contractual arrangements to circumvent tax obligations. The aim is to ensure that the tax cost and material risks are identified and understood in time and managed before the contract is signed, rather than coming as an unpleasant surprise after the deal is closed.

In my Contract Tax Review Insights series, I will explore the most common tax traps in international business contracts, one by one, and explain how they can be identified before it is too late.

Next topic: When does VAT on a seemingly standard contract become a real cost for a FinTech company?

Comments are closed.

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.